Op-Ed: Sacramento needs to quit dumping extra costs on Californians
Regional News
Audio By Carbonatix
6:43 AM on Monday, November 16
The state of California Department of Justice is suing a landfill that stopped accepting trash nearly two years ago.
On Oct. 27, Attorney General Rob Bonta announced a lawsuit against the operators of Chiquita Canyon Landfill in Castaic.
But this court case wastes public money and will solve nothing for residents struggling with an ongoing cost-of-living crisis.
When Chiquita stopped accepting waste on Jan. 1, 2025, residents didn’t suddenly stop generating garbage. They kept living as they always have, only now their trash costs a lot more to get rid of.
The case also exposes a weakness in California’s approach to serious state challenges. For Sacramento, it is easier to play the blame game than to fix big problems that require big thinking.
No one can doubt that Chiquita Canyon Landfill has caused problems for local residents. After an underground chemical reaction released foul-smelling gases and contaminated liquids, many reported nausea, headaches, dizziness, and breathing difficulties.
Now politicians are causing problems of a different kind.
In December 2024, Los Angeles County Supervisor Kathryn Barger warned that the closure could bring “price gouging” and promised to examine its effects on waste services.
What’s happened to help Californians since then? Not a lot.
The county’s own subsequent figures make that problem clear.
Waste hauler Burrtec had to transport material through Sun Valley to Simi Valley Landfill, where disposal fees were nearly three times higher.
County supervisors approved an additional $6.61 monthly charge for customers in an unincorporated Santa Clarita Valley franchise area, explicitly attributing the increase to Chiquita’s closure. Including a separate annual adjustment, the full monthly rate rose from $37.49 to $44.67.
The rerouting also adds an estimated 52,000 truck miles a year. Which is something you’d think would alarm left-leaning politicians who claim to care about the environment.
That hypocrisy isn’t surprising. California has a habit of making environmental problems worse while claiming to solve them, then blaming whatever trendy problem is in vogue that season rather than confronting its own failures.
Just look at the devastating Los Angeles wildfires in January 2025. What was held responsible? Climate change — of course.
But while hot, dry conditions undoubtedly made the fires more dangerous, they don’t explain everything. Fires need to be ignited, after all.
Later, federal prosecutors alleged that a man deliberately started the fire that became the deadly Palisades blaze. He denied the charges. His first trial ended in a mistrial after 10 of 12 jurors favored acquittal, and a second trial began this month.
Meanwhile, residents had spent years warning about flammable brush growing on public land.
A Wall Street Journal investigation found that a maze of government agencies and regulations made it harder to clear dangerous vegetation. In one case, residents faced a $150 fee just to remove brush from state parkland.
California can’t stop every wildfire. It can at least try to help people protect their homes. In fact, that should be a basic government responsibility.
The same questions hung over Proposition 45, which was defeated last week. The measure would have imposed deadlines on environmental reviews and legal challenges for essential infrastructure projects, including wildfire prevention measures.
What good are those protections if bureaucracy prevents essential work from getting done?
None of this gives Chiquita Canyon operators a free pass. If they broke the law, they should face the consequences.
But Californians deserve more than lawsuits, political grandstanding, and higher garbage bills.
We need a safe, affordable place to dispose of our waste, and we need environmental problems fixed before they become disasters.
Most of all, we need a government that takes responsibility for delivering solutions rather than always looking for someone else to blame.